After watching Crimson Peak (Guillermo del Toro, 2015) and The Devil’s Backbone (Guillermo del Toro, 2001) as a class we watched another film in a similar genre to these two: The Orphanage (J.A. Bayona, 2007). Whilst The Orphanage wasn’t directed by Guillermo del Toro, he did produce it.
![the-orphanage-screenshot-2](https://filmstudiesleeb.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/the-orphanage-screenshot-2.png?w=647&h=274)
The film opens in Spain in 1975 where Laura, a young orphan, is adopted. We then return to see her years later with her husband Carlos and their adopted seven-year-old son Simon planning to reopen the orphanage she grew up in as a house for disabled children . Simon claims to have met someone named Tomas, a young boy wearing a sack mask. Laura is visited by Benigna, a social worker, and as an audience we learn that Tomas is HIV positive; Laura asks Benigna to leave after her inquiries become too intrusive. She then finds Benigna in the coal shed later that night but is unable to catch her before she flees. Simon discovers he was adopted through a childish game including clues, he tells Laura that his new friend told him that he will die soon. During the opening party for the orphanage, Simon hides from Laura after an argument. While looking for him Laura is trapped in the bathroom by a child wearing a sack mask. After escaping she finds that Simon is missing; one of the head police offices suggests that Benigna may have abducted him. The film then jumps 6 months, Simon is still missing, Laura spots Benigna in the street but she is run over and killed by a car shortly after. Investors discovers that Benigna used to work at the orphanage and had a secret child with a deformed face, the child was kept hidden from the others and always wore a sack mask which was once stolen from him by the other children causing him to become embarrassed and hide in a cave before being drowned by the sea. Laura discovers the remains of the orphans she grew up with in the orphanage’s coal shed and it is revealed that Benigna poisoned all their meals which killed them as revenge for them “killing” her son. Laura’s husband Carlos leaves the orphanage overwhelmed by his wife’s speculations. After he has left Laura gives the orphanage a makeover so it resembles the one she grew up in and she attempts to contact the children’s spirits by playing an old game with them. She is led by them to a hidden underground room where inside she finds Simon’s corpse wearing Tomas’s sack mask. A realisation hits Laura that whilst she was looking for Simon she moved pieces of construction scaffolding therefore blocking the entrance to the hidden room, Simon was trapped inside and fell and broke his neck. Laura takes an overdose of sleeping pills and as she dies the children’s spirits alongside Simon’s appear.
![maxresdefault](https://filmstudiesleeb.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/maxresdefault-e1510257842447.jpg?w=656&h=274)
Personally, I wasn’t as keen at first on this film as some of the others we had watched. The first half seemed to have a few pacing issues for me however, this was outweighed by the brilliant second half. The suspense created as different layers and possibilities to the story were revealed increased my curiosity more and more. My favourite scene of the entire film was no doubt the scene in which Laura starts playing the knock on the wall game, that we previously saw her playing as a young girl, in an attempt to contact and play with the orphan’s spirits. The scene was wonderfully thrilling and suspenseful with a great build up as we are shown the progression of the spirits participation in the game through a series of camera pans. Whilst watching the scene I definitely got goosebumps and was unable to shake the chills in gave me; perhaps this was due to the juxtaposition between this darkly lit location with little sound other than Laura speaking and the children’s footsteps; and the opening scene of the film showing the orphans playing the same game on a bright sunny day. The opening scene was full of energy and happiness whereas the replicant scene later on was much more suspenseful and uncanny, it was a detail of the film that I was very impressed with.
Due to The Orphanage not being directed by Guillermo del Toro, there are clear differences between the appearance of the “ghosts” in this film compared to the others we have watched. In Crimson Peak and The Devil’s Backbone the ghosts appeared to be very deformed particularly the black and red older ghosts in Crimson Peak whereas the ghosts that appears in The Orphanage look extremely normal like normal children which is in some ways more uncanny. However, despite the differences in terms of exterior, the interior and what the “ghosts” represent is very similar. The Orphanage continues the reoccurring theme of ghosts being a possible figment of the imagination rather than a legitimate supernatural being. In this case the ghosts seem to on be able to be seen by those who are about to die, Simon claimed he could see Tomas and his other friends in the days leading up to his death, the medium could suppossedly see the orphans and later revealed she was ‘close to death’ and then Laura (the only one that we as an audience see interact with the spirits) is only able to see them moments before her own death.